Openresty and Nginx 1.11.x

zxcvbn4038 · 2016-06-27T12:00:35+00:00

Hello! On Fri, Jul 1, 2016 at 1:29 PM, Ingo Sauerzapf wrote: > Understood, but I am wondering why a local function xyz in my zookeeper.lua > file is n...

Openresty and Nginx 1.11.x

zxcvbn4038

I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

info

Can you be a bit more specific about the problem? like .conf/error logging.

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 6:00:35 AM UTC+2, CJ Ess wrote:

I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

zxcvbn4038

Sure, this is the problem I ran into which was fixed in nginx 1.11.0 -

http://hg.nginx.org/nginx/rev/ce94f07d5082

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 12:00:35 AM UTC-4, CJ Ess wrote:

I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

info

You can always run a diff but we compiled 2 days ago against the dev(hg) version including the 2 (not yet released) new h2 fixes, dynamic tls and all works fine so you may have to build an out of bound yourself.

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 6:15:39 PM UTC+2, CJ Ess wrote:

Sure, this is the problem I ran into which was fixed in nginx 1.11.0 -

http://hg.nginx.org/nginx/rev/ce94f07d5082

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 12:00:35 AM UTC-4, CJ Ess wrote:
I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

zxcvbn4038

So the question is if Openresty modifies the nginx source files in the bundle directory - if not then I should be able to drop in nginx 1.11 with only a few changes. If there are changes applied before the release then I'd be better off patching the 1.9.15 files. It appears that the patch from 1.11.0 applies cleanly, I'm still in the process of testing.

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 12:00:35 AM UTC-4, CJ Ess wrote:

I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

info

A quick search leads to this patch https://forum.nginx.org/read.php?29,263832,263832
which works and we use. Maybe agentzh has a list somewhere detailing nginx patches still waiting but are save to apply.

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 10:28:37 PM UTC+2, CJ Ess wrote:

So the question is if Openresty modifies the nginx source files in the bundle directory - if not then I should be able to drop in nginx 1.11 with only a few changes. If there are changes applied before the release then I'd be better off patching the 1.9.15 files. It appears that the patch from 1.11.0 applies cleanly, I'm still in the process of testing.

On Monday, June 27, 2016 at 12:00:35 AM UTC-4, CJ Ess wrote:
I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx site, will it be the next version in Openresty?

If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1 today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?

agentzh

Hello!

On Sun, Jun 26, 2016 at 9:00 PM, CJ Ess wrote:
> I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in
> Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx
> site, will it be the next version in Openresty?
>

The next version of OpenResty will be 1.9.15.2, still with the nginx
1.9.15 core. Upgrading to the nginx 1.11.x should be the release after
1.9.15.2 is out (in July).

> If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1
> today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has
> the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?
>

It takes quite some time to test the compatibility of all the
OpenResty components against every new nginx core. Regressions in new
nginx cores happen from time to time. To get an idea about what the
testing looks like, see

    https://qa.openresty.org/

OpenResty maintains a list of patches for the nginx core. See

    https://github.com/openresty/openresty/tree/master/patches/

Regards,
-agentzh

zxcvbn4038

Cool, I understand the process and timeline now.

I can tell you that the http/2 fix patched clearnly to Openresty 1.9.15.1, so I am pretty confident that will hold me over until the Openresty 1.11.0 release.

On Wed, Jun 29, 2016 at 4:58 PM, Yichun Zhang (agentzh) <age...@gmail.com> wrote:

Hello!

On Sun, Jun 26, 2016 at 9:00 PM, CJ Ess wrote:
> I ran into a problem with Nginx's http/2 implementation and I need a fix in
> Nginx 1.11.x. That version is listed as the mainline version on the Nginx
> site, will it be the next version in Openresty?
>

The next version of OpenResty will be 1.9.15.2, still with the nginx
1.9.15 core. Upgrading to the nginx 1.11.x should be the release after
1.9.15.2 is out (in July).

> If I wanted to try jumping the gun and getting Openresty w/ Nginx 1.11.1
> today, is it a simple as trading out what is in the Bundle directory? Or has
> the Nginx in the bundle directory been modified?
>

It takes quite some time to test the compatibility of all the
OpenResty components against every new nginx core. Regressions in new
nginx cores happen from time to time. To get an idea about what the
testing looks like, see

https://qa.openresty.org/

OpenResty maintains a list of patches for the nginx core. See

https://github.com/openresty/openresty/tree/master/patches/

Regards,
-agentzh

.